P-ISSN: 2808-5957
E-ISSN: 2808-6724
ijoms.internationaljournallabs.com
1165
LEGAL CERTAINTY OF AUTHORITY OF LOCAL REGULATIONS
CONCERNING ZAKAT MANAGEMENT IN STATE ADMINISTRATIVE
LAW PERSPECTIVE
1
Muhammad Helmi Fahrozi,
2
Suprima
1,2
Faculty of Law, Jakarta Veterans National Development University
Email: helmifakrazi@upnvj.ac.id, suprima01@gmail.com
ARTICLE INFO
ABSTRACT
Date received: 15 June 2022
Revision date : 27 June 2022
Date received : 07 July 2022
Keywords: Legal Certainty,
Zakat, State Administrative
Law.
This study wants to show a solution that the latest regulation
on zakat, namely Law number 23 of 2011 concerning Zakat
Management, can be the basis for the formation of regional
regulations, through qualitative research methods, based on
library research and emphasizing literature review. This study
suggests that the formation of regional regulations on zakat
management has strong legal certainty, because Indonesia is
a state of law, and generally Indonesia uses state
administrative law in carrying out its duties and responsibilities
carried out by state administrators, in this case the
government. Zakt is the main support for the life of the nation
and society. Therefore, the law on zakat regulations from the
legal aspect of state administration, the urgency of the
formation of zakat regulations is important so that its
legitimacy is regulated.
This work is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0
INTRODUCTION
The constitutionality of Regional Regulations (hereinafter referred to as Perda) is
the basis for the community's need to develop their region. Perda was born from the
womb of people's thoughts through its actors, namely the regional government
(hereinafter referred to as Pemda), this became part of the unifying component of the
nation to strengthen diversity within the framework of the Unitary State of the Republic
of Indonesia (NKRI). In addition, regional regulations are formed in order to create the
widest possible opportunities for regions so that they can be independent and prosper
Legal Certainty Of Authority Of Local Regulations Concerning Zakat Management In
State Administrative Law Perspective
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
, Vol 1 (10), Juli 2022
1166
the people in the region according to the potential or capacity and characteristics of the
regional community itself (Bungaran, 2012).
It is appropriate when local people want to be more organized and orderly, then
they must follow the regulations that have been made by the local government itself,
the regulations formed by the local government are regulating the wider community
(public law), according to Gordon the rules governing the wider community are part of
state administrative law In addition, the rules governing the wider community are
drawn up by the government consisting of the executive, legislature and courts. In the
regional context, there is no single party that has more authority than the local
government itself which creates and exercises the power to regulate the local
community, meaning that this has meaning that it is the government that creates the
rules and the government is also the one who embodies these rules into government
programs and or activities. Government programs and activities are regulated in the
legal codification of regional regulations as part of state administrative law, this is for
the sake of creating justice and order in local communities.
Departing from the basis of state law, in Article 18 paragraph 6 of the 1945
Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, it is emphasized that regional governments
have the full right to stipulate a regional regulation, this is in order to carry out
autonomy and assistance tasks. Each regional head and the Regional People's
Representative Council (DPRD) are given the same authority, namely the authority to
form laws or legislative authority.
Generally, regional regulations formed by local governments are not small, often
local regulations are made to meet various kinds of problems in very complex aspects
of community life, and these problems are relegated to regional regulations in order to
prioritize the interests of the people, problems that often arise in the community are
aspects of the economy or growth. regional welfare development (Angkadai, 2020).
In building the economy, both at the central and regional levels, in principle, it
has an open nature, meaning that the state provides the widest possible opportunities
to anyone to help and develop the country's economy and for the welfare of the people.
As a country that has citizens whose majority are Muslim, a well-known economic
practice is carried out because of the nature of its obligations that must be carried out
by each individual Muslim, namely the practice of carrying out zakat worship. The
practice of zakat has an important role in the economy of citizens and the progress of
the civilization of the Indonesian nation.
If you look at the potential for zakat in Indonesia in 2021 to reach 327.6 trillion,
then the potential for zakat practice in Indonesia is very possible to help the country's
economy (Lorensia, Canggih, & Wijaya, 2012). In the regulatory aspect, the fact is that
it has not been in tune with the large potential of zakat and can be used by the
Legal Certainty Of Authority Of Local Regulations Concerning Zakat Management In
State Administrative Law Perspective
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
, Vol 1 (10), Juli 2022
1167
community to its full potential. Zakat regulation still needs to be reviewed, because Law
Number 23 of 2011 concerning Zakat Management (hereinafter referred to as UUPZ)
has not comprehensively accommodated regional interests.
Today, the zakat regulation is considered to be contrary to the higher laws and
regulations, namely the law, the conflict is a problem that to this day has no solution.
As a result, every local regulation that is made has no relevance to (Muhtada, 2017). Or
with another meaning, the zakat regulation that was formed today is not in accordance
with the concept of the hierarchical theory of laws and regulations, It is this
discontinuity that ultimately requires the zakat regulation to have legal certainty. As a
state of law and a country that has the largest Muslim community in the world. Legal
certainty of regional regulations on zakat is an urgency that cannot be ruled out,
because, without legal certainty, regional regulations on zakat which are very much
needed by local people have no legitimacy.
Currently, the legal certainty of the formation of regional regulations on zakat
cannot officially have legitimate legitimacy, because in the provisions of laws and
regulations, religion is not an entity that may be regulated by the Regional Government,
while the regional regulations on zakat which in fact talk about religion are the authority
of the central government. this can be seen in Law 32 of 2014 concerning Regional
Government. The starting point of this paper is to find out how legal certainty is
regarding the formation of regional regulations on zakat. In principle, legal certainty is a
form of protection for justice seekers against arbitrary actions by regulators, or in other
contexts legal certainty can be addressed to the needs of citizens in carrying out
activities so as not to get out of the state of law (legitimate) (Mertokusumo & Pitlo,
1993).
This means that a person can and is allowed to do something in a legal state
because the actions and behavior of a citizen have been regulated in positive law. If it
is concluded why legal certainty in the formation of regional regulations regarding zakat
is important, namely to meet the needs of the community and the welfare of the people
through legal aspects (Fakhrazi, 2017).
In state administrative law, not only people whose actions and behavior are
regulated as Indonesian citizens, even the main principles of state administrative law
regulate the actions and internal behavior of the government itself. The concept of
government governing society.
METHOD
The method used in this research is a normative juridical law research method.
Normative research that uses a statute approach by examining various legal rules
(Efendi, 2016). This study uses a library research system to find legal materials relevant
Legal Certainty Of Authority Of Local Regulations Concerning Zakat Management In
State Administrative Law Perspective
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
, Vol 1 (10), Juli 2022
1168
to this research. The data sources used are primary data with primary, secondary, and
tertiary legal materials. The analysis used is qualitative analysis, adhering to the
characteristics of law as an applied science
RESULT AND DISCUSSION
1. Legal Certainty Regional regulations regarding Zakat Management
Regarding the principle of legal certainty, in fact the existence of this principle
is interpreted as a condition where the law is certain because of the concrete power
of the law in question. The existence of the principle of legal certainty is a form of
protection for justice (seeking justice) against arbitrary actions, which means that a
person will and can get something that is expected under certain circumstances.
(Mertokusumo, 1993). This statement is in line with what Van Apeldoorn said that
legal certainty has two aspects, namely that the law can be determined in concrete
terms and legal security. This means that the party seeking justice wants to know
what is the law in a particular case before starting a case and protection for justice
seekers. From this view, it can be understood that without legal certainty, people
do not know what to do and in the end, uncertainty arises which will eventually
lead to chaos due to the indecisiveness of the legal system. Thus, legal certainty
refers to the application of a clear, permanent and consistent law where its
implementation cannot be influenced by subjective circumstances (Prayogo, 2016).
Although it is said that legal principles are the heart of legal regulations, they
cannot be equated between legal principles and legal norms in the form of positive
law. Legal principles only regulate and explain (explanation), where the aim is only
to provide an overview and is not normative.9 Therefore, legal principles do not
include positive law and certainly cannot be applied directly to resolve legal
disputes. In this case, Van Eikema Hommes explicitly said that legal principles
should not be considered as concrete legal norms, but should be viewed as general
principles or guidelines for applicable law (Notohamidjojo, 1975).
One indicator of a country's economic development is the development of
human capital (Uddin & Masih, 2015). Human capital in the form of health capital
and education capital is realized as a form of joint investment in developing the
economy. Both act as inputs in order to obtain higher incomes, and as outputs that
affect the welfare of society as a whole (Todaro, Michael P., 2011).
Human development is defined as a process of increasing the capability of
humans or populations to be able to participate in all areas of development, and to
lead a healthy and productive life in society (Alkire, 2010); Hassan et al. 2017).
Human development has a broader meaning than economic growth, more than just
increasing income and the process of producing goods and capital accumulation.
Legal Certainty Of Authority Of Local Regulations Concerning Zakat Management In
State Administrative Law Perspective
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
, Vol 1 (10), Juli 2022
1169
The underlying reason why human development needs attention is that many
developing countries including Indonesia have achieved economic growth, but have
failed to reduce the poverty gap (Asmita & Ruslan, 2017).
Zakat according to terminology means, a certain amount of property that is
required by Allah SWT. To be given to the mustahik who have been mentioned in
the Qur'an. Zakat can also mean a number of assets given to certain people.
Pronunciation of zakat zakat can mean a number of assets taken from the assets of
those who pay zakat. Syukri Ghozali stated that zakat. is a certain part of the
wealth that is given by a person as a right of Allah to those who are entitled to
receive it, including the poor, according to Islamic religious provisions. As for the
wealth that is distributed, it is called zaka, and the word zakat means to increase, to
be holy, to change, because with the issuance of zakat, the property is expected to
increase, be holy, and be a blessing to (Afifi & Ika, 2010).
Zakat has great virtue for those who pay it. The effects of zakat are very large
and useful for individuals and the people, because zakat is worship for Allah,
namely:
1. Get a high position; Zakat can increase the position of a servant to become a
robbani. Humans will reach this level when they have been separated from the
love of the world (especially the love of wealth) and become servants of Allah
alone, not servants of dinars or dirhams. This is as conveyed by the prophet
SAW:
2. Therapy of love of property; love of treasure is a dangerous and chronic disease.
By slander, humans are created to love wealth. Humans cannot be separated
from the love of wealth that makes them inhabit the bottom of hell except by
issuing zakat every year
The wisdom of issuing zakat is as follows:
1. Cleanse the soul from the disease of miserly miserly if this disease overwhelms a
person's soul, he is unable to escape from it. This disease brings the wrath and
hatred of God. The treasure is not on the Day of Resurrection and will turn into
sheets where the owner will be roasted in the Hellfire.
2. Happy world and hereafter; is in the form of increased wealth and blessings,
because people who donate part of their wealth will be multiplied by Allah SWT.
In addition to the happiness of the world, zakat is also a medicine for the sick
and brings health and safety. As for the happiness of the hereafter, it is in the
form of eradicating bad and increasing goodness, besides that zakat is a way to
forgiveness and good luck reaching heaven. In fact, to reach the highest level
in heaven.
Legal Certainty Of Authority Of Local Regulations Concerning Zakat Management In
State Administrative Law Perspective
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
, Vol 1 (10), Juli 2022
1170
3. Avoiding and holding grudges from the poor; The envy and envy of these poor
people can turn into hostility, trying to steal and confiscate their property, even
killing and stealing their property. But if the rich are gentle towards the poor,
share with the poor, look at orphans and widows with a look of compassion and
help those in need a helping hand, this attitude will make him loved by the
poor. He also felt safe, calm, and peaceful.
4. Prayer for muzakki from people who receive zakat; It is recommended to pray
for the person who gives zakat by saying good things so that he will be
expanded his sustenance and be safe in the hereafter (Muhammad, 2012).
Sector in the economy is an important object in the discussion of zakat.
Through this sector, it can be used as a barometer of progress and improvement of
a country's economy. In other words, zakat can play an important role in reducing
and eradicating the poor, with the management and use of zakat funds in a
targeted and equitable manner, an increasing economy will certainly be achieved,
and the poor will be eroded by themselves. A development can be said to be
successful if the process is able to improve the community's economy in the long
term. The economy is reflected in the excellent quality of the community's
economy, an adequate level of education, along with a high level of per capita
income. The obligation to issue zakat has a strong foundation as the achievement
of a high-income country to create an economy for housing and other necessities of
life (Hamid, 2006).
Positive relationship between zakat and human development in Indonesia.
That is, by increasing or decreasing the nominal amount of zakat, it will affect the
increase or decrease in health, education, and income of mustahik. Therefore, it
can be concluded that zakat can play an important role in improving the welfare of
the community, especially mustahik.
2. Zakat Regulations in The Perspective of State Administrative Law
The administration of government must also be based on rules or regulations
in order to provide services and protection for the basic rights of the community, on
the other hand the rules or regulations that serve as the basis for carrying out the
duties or functions of the government are made by the government organs or
institutions themselves so that This is something that the makers of the rules or
regulations really need to pay attention to, so that it really accommodates the
interests of the community. Autonomy in a narrow sense can be interpreted as
"independent". While a broader meaning is defined as "powerful". Regional
autonomy thus means the independence of a region in terms of making and making
Legal Certainty Of Authority Of Local Regulations Concerning Zakat Management In
State Administrative Law Perspective
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
, Vol 1 (10), Juli 2022
1171
decisions regarding the interests of its own region. If the region is able to achieve
the conditions required by the region, it can be said that the region is empowered
(capable) to do anything independently without pressure and coercion from
outsiders and of course adapted to regional conditions and needs.
Various definitions of Regional Autonomy have been put forward by many
experts, and it can be concluded that regional autonomy is the authority of an
autonomous region to regulate and manage the interests of the local community
according to its own initiative (initiative) based on community aspirations in
accordance with statutory regulations. Meanwhile, the autonomous region itself is a
legal community unit that has certain regional boundaries and is authorized to
regulate and manage the interests of the local community according to its own
initiative based on the aspirations of the community in the Unitary State of the
Republic of Indonesia.
to change the governance of Indonesia which at that time was centralized to
decentralized with regional autonomy. It also demands further reforms in which
regional governments are given the authority to administer their regions as
mandated by Article 18 of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia. Post-
reformation with a decentralized and regional autonomy system provides a logical
understanding that local government, especially DPRD in its position and function,
has shifted from central coordination with a centralized system to a decentralized
and regional autonomy system based on arrangements mandated by laws and
regulations or clearly affirmed as part of the function. and the authority of the
regional government, especially the DPRD as one of the regional government
administration institutions.
In relation to that understanding, the use of legal language, in Article 18
paragraph (6) contains the phrase "has the right to stipulate Regional Regulations"
and "Article 38 of Law Number 5 of 1974, it is stated that regional heads with the
approval of the Regional People's Representative Council (DPRD) are authorized to
stipulate local regulation" (Rosjidi, 1998).
Produk hukum merupakan hukum yang dihasilkan dari berbagai macam unsur
dengan pengelompokan atau penghierarkian tertentu berdasarkan lingkup
berlakunya. Produk hukum yang legal (Theo, 2005) dipahami sebagai hasil dari
perumusan lembaga atau badan atau pejabat yang berwenang untuk itu.
In relation to the process of "forming" this regional regulation, there are
important things that need to be stated so that it becomes a serious concern
regarding how to produce or produce a regional regulation. Law No. 12 of 2011
concerning the Establishment of Legislation requires the existence of “openness”
(see letter g of the Law). In the explanation of letter g, it is stated that:
Legal Certainty Of Authority Of Local Regulations Concerning Zakat Management In
State Administrative Law Perspective
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
, Vol 1 (10), Juli 2022
1172
“In the process of forming laws and regulations, starting from planning,
drafting, discussing the ratification or stipulation and promulgation, it is transparent
and open. Thus, all levels of society have the widest opportunity to provide input in
the formation of laws and regulations
Related to that, in Article 96 of Law no. 12 of 2011 also states that: "The
public has the right to provide input orally and/or in writing in the Formation of
Legislation". In Article 237 paragraph (3) of Law no. 23 of 2014, states that "The
community has the right to provide input orally and/or in writing in the formation of
a regional regulation". Still in relation to that, the role of the community in the
process of forming laws and regulations (Perda) is carried out by taking into
account the principles of access to information and participation.
The function of formulating regional regulations is a right that is embodied in
the formal power of the legislature granted by law, which is called authority. The
concept of "right to formulate" local regulations is related to the meaning of
"formation" of local regulations as stated in Article 96 paragraph (1) letter a, that
"Provincial DPRD has the following functions: "formation of provincial regulations"
and Article 149 paragraph (1) letter a, that "DPRD districts/cities have functions
establishment of district/city regulations”, and “right to stipulate” local
regulations, and based on article 18 paragraph (6) it is stated: “Local governments
have the right to stipulate regional regulations and other regulations to carry out
autonomy and assistance tasks”. There is the word "set". Based on article 20
paragraph (1) it is stated that: "The House of Representatives holds the power to
form laws". There is the word "form". The formal power to "form" regulations
(laws) rests with the legislative body called the DPR but does not mention the
executive (president), and the formal power to "stipulate" regulations (perda) rests
with the Regional Government. There is no mention of the legislative
(provincial/district/city DPRD) or executive (governor/regent/mayor).
Based on the 1945 Constitution, the formal power to "form" laws is left to the
DPR, not to the President, let alone the DPRD. Based on the law related to regional
autonomy, it is stated that the formal power of “formation” of regional regulations
is by the DPRD, while the Governor, Regent/Mayor only participate in joint
discussions (Widodo Ekatjahjana, 2008).
According to the author's analysis, the comparison of sentences in a series of
articles contains similarities or even similarities in terminology used in legislative
institutions at the central and regional levels, namely "forming" and "forming".
Thus, the legal power of the DPR's "power" is the same as that of the DPRD
because the powers of the two institutions are discussed with the term "form" as
Legal Certainty Of Authority Of Local Regulations Concerning Zakat Management In
State Administrative Law Perspective
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
, Vol 1 (10), Juli 2022
1173
the origin or basis of the word. Meanwhile, the 1945 Constitution states in the word
"stipulate" regional regulations for the scope of the region.
Thus, in order not to have similar terminology and multiple interpretations, the
law should have been revised, because if it is not revised it seems as if the legal
powers or legal authorities of different levels become equal. The context of the
1945 Constitution regarding the powers of the DPR is clearly stated as a law-
making institution while regional governments are stated to have the right to
stipulate local regulations, so it is not the formation of local regulations as intended
in the related law. To overcome the ambiguity of the legal meaning of the 1945
Constitution and other related laws, it is more like "the right to formulate or
formulate" for the regional scope by the DPRD within the framework of "stipulation"
as a harmonizing meaning related to "regulatory functions in the regional scope.
Based on these descriptions, the context of "formation of regional regulations"
in the framework of regional autonomy requires the attachment of certain
"authorities" to carry out the functioning of regional government. Therefore,
regional governments are given certain "rights" in the division of affairs. Regarding
that explanation, as stated by Abdul Latif that: “The Regional People's
Representative Council is equipped with initiative rights and the right to make
changes. Even the agreement itself contains the authority to determine
(dicicive)”.the other hand, there is a normative narrative that shows the concept of
“determination” so that contradictory meanings are reflected in the normative link
of the existing institutional functions. In the regulation it is stated that: "Regional
regulations are stipulated by the Regional Head after obtaining joint approval from
the Regional People's Representative Council." (UU 32 Tahun 2004) Based on the
explanation above, a comparison of concepts appears in which the normative level
of the concept of proposed legal structures leads to systematic structural problems
regarding the existence of DPR and DPRD institutions in the context of central and
regional affairs. The legal consequences that arise are none other than a kind of
dualism of power in producing rules. Such legal consequences lead to the
equalization of the power of the "legislative institution" because two legislative
institutions with different scopes of function have the "same" power. handover of
affairs from the center to the regions within the framework of implementing
regional autonomy.
CONCLUSION
This study confirms that, even though local regulations do not have strong
legitimacy in the law, currently zakat regulations are still very much needed by local
Legal Certainty Of Authority Of Local Regulations Concerning Zakat Management In
State Administrative Law Perspective
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
, Vol 1 (10), Juli 2022
1174
people. Not only is it needed in an economic context that can support the life and
welfare of the community, zakat is also the backbone of social life to build the life of the
nation, state to the smallest level of society as a guarantee of an orderly safe and
prosperous. Departing from the perspective of State Administrative Law, the regional
regulations concerning zakat management which were formed by the Regional
Representatives Council together with the executives in the regions, should still be
implemented, because the most important principles carried out by stakeholders in the
regions are the general principles of good governance.
Therefore, regional regulations are principally the rights and authorities of local
governments. And the community can only be reached effectively not at the central
government, so it cannot be ruled out that the local government is obliged to provide
space for regional formation regarding zakat management in the area if the area is first
filled by Muslims, secondly zakat management is very much needed by the community,
and thirdly zakat is zakat. one of the main elements in sustaining the economy in the
area.
REFERENCE
Afifi, Agus Thayib, & Ika, Shabira. (2010). Kekuatan Zakat Hidup Berkah Rezeki
Melimpah.
Yogyakarta: Galangpress Center
.
Alkire, Sabina. (2010). Human development: Definitions, critiques, and related
concepts.
UNDP-HDRO Occasional Papers
, (2010/1).
Angkadai, Yoseph Fenly. (2020).
Hak Menetapkan Peraturan Daerah Untuk
Melaksanakan Otonomi Daerah Dan Tugas Pembantuan
. Universitas Tadulako.
Asmita, Fitrawaty, & Ruslan, Dede. (2017). Analysis of factors affecting the human
development index in north sumatra province.
IOSR Journal of Business and
Management (IOSR-JBM)
,
19
(10), 27–36.
Bungaran, Satria. (2012).
Pengaruh Penerapan Metode Pembelajaran Peta Pikiran (Mind
Map) Terhadap Hasil Belajar Siswa Pada Materi Pokok Gaya Dan Hukum Newton Di
Kelas Viii Semester Ii Smp Negeri 2 Gebangt. P 2011/2012
. UNIMED.
Fakhrazi, Muhammad Helmi. (2017). Perluasan Wewenang Mahkamah Konstitusi Dalam
Memutus Sengketa Kewenangan Antar Lembaga Negara Hingga Lembaga
Pemerintahan Tingkat Pusat dan Daerah.
STAATSRECHT: Indonesian Constitutional
Law Journal
,
1
(1).
Legal Certainty Of Authority Of Local Regulations Concerning Zakat Management In
State Administrative Law Perspective
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
, Vol 1 (10), Juli 2022
1175
Hamid, Arifin. (2006). Hukum Zakat Pengembangan dan Pendayagunaannya.
Makassar:
Umitoha Ukhuwah Grafika
.
Lorensia, Amelia, Canggih, Beny, & Wijaya, Rizkia Indra. (2012).
Drug interaction
analysis in hospitalized and outpatient care of asthma patient in Adi Husada
Undaan Wetan Hospital, Surabaya, Indonesia
.
Mertokusumo, Sudikno, & Pitlo, A. (1993). Bab-bab tentang Penemuan Hukum,
Bandung: PT.
Citra Aditya Bakti
.
Muhammad, Daud All. (2012).
Hukum Islam: Pengantar Ilmu Hukum dan Tata Hukum
Islam di Indonesia
. Rajagrafindo.
Muhtada, Dani. (2017). The prospects for public management reform in Indonesia.
JILS
,
2
, 145.
Notohamidjojo, O. (1975). Soal-soal Pokok Filsafat Hukum, Jakarta: BPK.
Gunung Mulia
.
Prayogo, R. Tony. (2016). Penerapan Asas Kepastian Hukum Dalam Peraturan
Mahkamah Agung Nomor 1 Tahun 2011 Tentang Hak Uji Materiil Dan Dalam
Peraturan Mahkamah Konstitusi Nomor 06/Pmk/2005 Tentang Pedoman Beracara
Dalam Pengujian Undang-Undang.
Jurnal Legislasi Indonesia
,
13
(2), 191–201.
Rosjidi, Ranggawidjaja. (1998). Pengantar Ilmu Perundang-undangan Indonesia.
Mandar Maju, Bandung
.
Todaro, Michael P., and Stephen C. Smith. (2011).
Pembangunan Ekonomi, Edisi
Kesebelas
. Jakarta: Erlangga.
Uddin, Md Akther, & Masih, Mansur. (2015).
Finance, growth and human development:
An Islamic economic development perspective
.
Widodo Ekatjahjana. (2008).
Pembentukan Peraturan Perundang-Undangan:
DasarDasar dan Teknik Penyusunannya
. Bandung: Citra Aditya Bakti.