P-ISSN: 2808-5957
E-ISSN: 2808-6724
ijoms.internationaljournallabs.com
1101
WOMEN'S CONTRIBUTION AS PROFESSIONALS AND WOMEN AS
ENTREPRENEURS TO THE WOMEN'S HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
INDEX (IPM) IN JAVA ISLAND
Qurrota Ayun¹, Imam Mukhlis
2
Universitas Negeri Malang, Jawa Timur, Indonesia
Email: qurrota.ayun1804326@student.um.ac.id, imammuklis23@gmail.com
ARTICLE INFO
ABSTRACT
Date received : 07 Juni 2022
Revision date : 15 Juni 2022
Date received : 25 Juni 2022
Indonesia faces the problem of a low HDI for women, this
problem is caused by the low contribution of women in the
country's economy. In fact, the HDI for women is still not
evenly distributed in all districts/cities throughout Indonesia.
In fact, the issue of HDI for women is not only a problem of
inequality in Java and outside Java, the problem of inequality
also occurs in regencies/cities on the island of Java. This study
intends to analyze the partial and simultaneous contribution of
women entrepreneurs and women's professional workers to
HDI women in Java. The research data uses secondary data in
the form of women's HDI data documents, data on women
entrepreneurs and data on women professional workers that
have been calculated by Central Bureau of Statistics, then the
data is analyzed using multiple linear regression and cross-
variable tests. The results of the study found that there was a
simultaneous positive influence on the contribution of women
entrepreneurs and professional women workers to the HDI of
women, partially only the variable of professional women
workers had a significant positive effect on the HDI of women.
While the variable of women as entrepreneurs has no
significant positive effect on women's HDI in Java.
Keywords: HDI Women;
Women Entrepreneurs;
Women Professionals.
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science © 2022 by International Journal Labs is licensed
under CC BY-SA 4.0
INTRODUCTION
The problem of gender equality in fact leaves homework unresolved, although in
terms of education, equality of women has been recognized, but in the economic field
the condition is not better. Women are often in disproportionate poverty, often women
are in the poorest conditions among the poorest. Conditions caused by limited equality in
access to resources make it difficult for women to grow economically. Often gender-
biased economic development occurs in developing countries, the severity of the
inequality occurs at various levels and fields of development (Khaerani, 2017). Even
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1102 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
though the contribution of the female workforce has a significant effect on economic
growth, a note from McKinsey mentions that countries that do not create an equal
environment will lose 12 trillion USD, equivalent to 16.5 percent of the total global
economy (McKinsey Global Institute, 2015). In the Asia Pacific region itself, there is
actually an increase in the workforce which provides opportunities for gender equality, so
there is a potential for economic revenue of USD 4.5 trillion to be received by each country
in 2025 (McKinsey Global Institute, 2018).
As one of the countries in the Asian region, Indonesia is in fact still facing the
problem of gender inequality, Indonesia's Human Development Index (IPM) is still below
the world average (KPPA and BPS, 2019). Even the female HDI ranking in Indonesia is
also far behind Singapore, Thailand, the Philippines and even Vietnam (UNDP, 2018). The
low HDI rating for women is due to the low contribution of women in the country's
economy. Indonesian women's Gross National Income (GNP) is in fact far behind
Singapore, Malaysia, Brunei, Thailand and the Philippines (UNDP, 2018). The low
participation of women in professional positions at the highest level also contributes to
the low HDI of women. Women's participation is still low, around half of the total
productive age women in the professional labor market, so women workers are still
concentrated in the informal sector (Dalilah, 2021). The involvement of women in the
formal sector is evidence of gender equality and women's empowerment, as countries
with developed economies continue to carry out sustainable economic development
(Sabariman, 2019). Women who manage to get out of their "domestic zone" to enter the
formal job market will open up new opportunities for other women so as to create a
transition to economic drivers and changes in the social landscape around them
(Sabariman, 2019). So it is not wrong if working in the formal sector becomes an
"achievement" for women in terms of higher education abilities, not just "helping" the
family economy (Cameron, Suarez, & Rowell, 2020).
It is not wrong if (Abdurrahman & Tusianti, 2021) provide solutions to increase
women's HDI through the contribution of women as professionals, women as
entrepreneurs and representation in parliament. It is time for the wrong mindset about
women to be changed through gender equality, placing women according to their
capabilities to achieve development goals, and including women in the development
process as assets and potential advantages (KPPPA, 2015). The fact is that until 2019,
the HDI of women (69.18) was far behind the HDI of men (75.96) there was a fairly wide
gap (KPPA and BPS, 2020).
Prejudice on the inability of women to occupy high positions is the reason that
women's positions in the top structure of positions are still limited and very minimal,
besides that at the same level of office there is a gap in the salary received by women
compared to men (Yaish & Kraus, 2003) ; ADB, 2016). The wage inequality between
women and men is proven by (Pirmana, 2006) that 23.34 percent of men receive higher
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1103 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
salaries/wages than women. The existence of discrimination in the wages received is a
potential barrier to the achievement of women's financial and economic independence
(Iskandar & Hamid, 2019). The condition of the gender gap reflects gender-based
discrimination in the labor market that does not look at the productivity of male workers
with female workers, even though there are already many professional positions that
should be able to be held by women with good educational backgrounds (ADB, 2016).
Provision of higher education is related to expertise and the existence of skills in
the field of formal work that must be possessed by female workers (Wijayanto & Sari,
2019). So it can be expected, low education, limited knowledge, and minimal expertise
will make it difficult for women to enter the formal sector, only the informal area which
ultimately provides an opportunity to be selected (Josephine, 2019). The provision of
education will hone skills so as to encourage productivity (Kamplemann, et al., 2018). A
study conducted by (Aisyah & Oktavilia, 2020) provides strong evidence of a significant
link between education and productivity that can be achieved by women. It is not
surprising that the dominance of women in cities with higher education backgrounds and
participation in formal work is higher than women in villages (Dalilah, 2021).
The condition of inequality is also still burdened by the existence of patriarchal
understanding causing the construction of women to be discriminatory and beneficial to
men (Safitri, 2014). The patriarchal culture also perpetuates the discrimination in wages
received by women in the labor market, found in 31 provinces in Indonesia (Iskandar &
Hamid, 2019). Even though providing a female leadership portion has a real impact on
company earnings, the Peterson Institute study found that 30 percent of women's
representation on the board of directors and C level will contribute 15 percent to the
company's net income (Noland, Moran, & Kotschwar, 2016).
Limited access forces women to enter the informal industry, which has various
complex problems that characterize it. The role of women in the micro-industrial labor
market cannot be ignored, data from the Ministry of Manpower records that as many as
70 percent of female workers are in the informal sector, and depend on it for a living.
This is early evidence of the high role of women in the informal sector, as well as the
limitations on established job opportunities in the formal labor market for women
(Ministry of Manpower, 2021). In poor families, the role of women becomes important to
help the family economy, the condition of powerlessness with low education demands
that the wife be empowered to help her husband who is economically inadequate (Anwas,
2013). The choices for part-time jobs that are usually done by women are house servants,
sellers, farm laborers, and home industry workers (Yuliati, 2019). The choice of the
informal sector on the one hand provides flexibility to female workers because of the
scope of work and work protocols offered but on the other hand the lack of guaranteed
wages, future work status, and the absence of professional training, career promotions
that are not obtained as formal workers.
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1104 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
The role of women in encouraging entrepreneurship is evidence of their adaptive
capacity and contribution, both in developed and developing countries, although access
is often discriminated against by (Jati, 2009). In Indonesia, the role of women in the
entrepreneurial sector is proven by the fact that the ownership of SMEs is very large,
from a total of 700 thousand SMEs, 34 percent are owned by women. These SMEs
contribute 22 percent to GDP, while women-owned SMEs contribute 9.1 percent to GDP.
Half of micro-enterprises and one-third of women-run enterprises contribute to economic
growth and job creation, on a par with male-owned enterprises. Although women are
faced with multiple responsibilities, in terms of business as well as family affairs and
household chores (IFC and USAID, 2016). This condition is due to the fact that female
entrepreneurs have the courage to take higher risks and are happy with challenges than
male entrepreneurs (Sherlywati, Handayani, & Harianti, 2017). In general, the obstacles
experienced by women in entrepreneurship can be classified into two, personal barriers
and structural barriers (Ardhanari, 2007).
This research has an urgency that the achievement of the Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) is still low due to the minimal contribution of women in the
economy, especially the role of women as professionals at high level positions and the
role of women as entrepreneurs. The existence of HDI disparities between women and
men's HDI during 2010-2019, is a question mark over the performance and efforts to
increase HDI through policies carried out by the government so far.
The condition of the HDI disparity is strong evidence of the gap in human
development in Indonesia between women and men. In addition, other evidence shows
the inequality of human development between Java and outside Java. This condition of
course also has an impact on the disparity in the HDI achievement of women in Java and
outside Java, but what is interesting is that the disparity in HDI achievement has in fact
also occurred in the provinces in Java itself, which in terms of infrastructure development
are better, this condition is certainly interesting for further studies. So that researchers
are interested in studying more deeply about the condition of the Women's HDI which is
predicted through the contribution of women in the economy represented by women as
professionals and women as entrepreneurs.
METHOD
Researchers set an associative quantitative approach to see the relationship
between the Women's Human Development Index (HDI) which will be predicted through
the factor of women's participation as entrepreneurs and professional workers. This study
chose the object of study in 34 cities and 85 districts on the island of Java as the object
of research. Secondary data of the research was taken through the BPS website, namely
the HDI data for women, female professionals and data on women entrepreneurs in 2019.
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1105 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
The HDI data for women was calculated using three components, namely health
referring to life expectancy data, education referring to data on average length of
schooling and expected years of schooling. , the economic component refers to a decent
standard of living through gross national income per capita in each district/city on the
island of Java (UNDP, 2020). Data on the percentage of women entrepreneurs is the
number of women entrepreneurs divided by the total number of entrepreneurs in each
district/city on the island of Java. Furthermore, the data on the percentage of women as
professional workers is the ratio of women as managers, professionals, administration
and technicians to all women in every district/city in Java Island. Furthermore, the data
obtained will be processed through the classical assumption test followed by using
multiple linear regression to see the partial and simultaneous contribution to the HDI of
women. The data is also cross-processed between independent variables and the
dependent variable to explain the contribution of each category to the HDI in women
descriptively.
RESULT AND DISCUSSION
The achievements of the HDI for Women in Java
Island, which is the center of government and the center of the Indonesian
economy, but still has complex issues of gender equality, this condition is certainly
interesting to observe, if so far there have been striking gaps in the HDI between Java
and outside Java, in fact there are many districts/cities. on the island of Java itself is still
struggling to overcome the HDI problem. Women's HDI in Java is still experiencing a
surprising disparity.
Figure 1. Women's HDI in Java Island in 2019
The research findings found that 5 percent of regions had a low Women's HDI and
only 8.4 percent of regions were categorized as very high in achieving Women's HDI.
There is a large gap in the achievement of HDI for women between regions on the island
of Java itself. What is interesting in the findings that the areas that have low HDI
0
10
20
30
40
50
5
49.6
37
8.4
IPM PEREM PUAN
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1106 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
achievements for women are also areas that are categorized as poor, such as Cianjur,
Garut, West Bandung from the West Java region. The East Java region is represented by
Sampang, Sumenep, while from Banten one district is Lebak. Regions that are able to
achieve a very high HDI for women are South Jakarta, East Jakarta, Bandung City,
Surakarta City, Salatiga City, Semarang City. Furthermore, from Yogyakarta Province
there are Sleman and Yogyakarta City, while East Java is only Malang City which is able
to achieve a very high female HDI.
1. Women Entrepreneurs in Java Island
Women who have a career in entrepreneurship have a high level of business
resilience when compared to businesses owned by men. Even with the double burden
they have, this condition proves that women's abilities in business management can be
contested. Of course managing a business for women has its own challenges, it is not
surprising that the involvement of women in the business world is not evenly distributed
in each region.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
RENDAH (<40 PERSEN)
SEDANG (40 PERSEN-49.99
PERSEN)
TINGGI (>50 PERSEN)
15.1
58
26.9
Perempuan Sebagai Pengusaha
Figure 2. Number of Women Entrepreneurs in Java Island in 2019
The involvement of women in the informal business sector is actually quite high,
but the ownership of independent formal businesses owned by women is indeed not as
large as that of men. Regions on the island of Java that have the number of women who
become entrepreneurs in the high category are only 26.9 percent, such as Central
Jakarta, Tasikmalaya, Purworejo, Wonosobo, Klaten, Rembang, Jepara, Demak,
Pekalongan, Pemalang, Salatiga City, and Tegal City. Furthermore, Yogyakarta Province
contributed very high the involvement of women in the business sector, in East Java
Province the areas of Ponorogo, Blitar, Kediri, Lumajang, Jember, Mojokerto, Nganjuk,
Ngawi, Bojonegoro, Kediri City, Blitar City and Batu City contributed very high
participation of women in entrepreneurship especially in the MSME sector. Regions with
women's participation as entrepreneurs who are in the low category are recorded at 15.1
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1107 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
percent which is contributed by the Thousand Islands from Jakarta Province, from West
Java it is recorded as Bogor, Sukabumi, Cianjur, Bandung, Garut, Majalengka, Indramayu,
West Bandung, and Kota Sukabumi. Meanwhile, from Central Java, areas with low female
participation in business ownership are Banjarnegara, Grobogan. Meanwhile, from East
Java Province, it was recorded that Situbondo, Sampang, Sumenep. Furthermore, Banten
Province recorded that Lebak, Tangerang and Serang City had low participation of women
as entrepreneurs.
2. Female Professional Workers in Java Island
Inequality of female professional workers in several areas in Java Island is still
happening, although every year the share of women who occupy professional worker
positions continues to increase. This condition causes the economic gap experienced by
women, on the other hand there is a gap in the wages received between women and
men, this difference is also the cause of the ratio of women's per capita expenditures
being lower, only 58.26 percent compared to men (BPS, 2020 ). Generally, the wages
received by women are always lower than the wages received by men both in rural and
urban areas. There seems to be an increase in the number of women entering the world
of professional work in some areas, although there are still many areas where women's
representation in professional work is still low.
rendah (<40
persen)
9%
sedang (40
persen-49.99
persen)
64%
tinggi (>50
persen)
27%
PEREMPUAN SEBAGAI PEKERJA PROFESIONAL
Figure 3. Number of Women as Professional Workers in Java in 2019
There are still as many as 9 percent of regions where the level of women's
involvement in professional work is low, such as the Province of West Java, which
accounts for the highest number, such as Sukabumi, Ciamis, Majalengka, Indramayu,
Purwakarta, Bekasi and West Bandung. From Central Java Province, Blora Regency was
donated, while East Java was from Pamekasan and Banten Province was only Lebak
Regency. Furthermore, the regions that have the contribution of women as professional
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1108 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
workers in the high category are 27 percent, while the regions that are in the medium
category are 64 percent very dominant which shows that there are already many regions
that have a portion of women's involvement in professional work. The increasing number
of women who have adequate educational backgrounds and competencies encourages
the share of women to enter available professional jobs.
a. Classical Assumption
Test Prerequisite tests that must be carried out before performing multiple linear
regression tests through the stages of normality, multicollinearity, autocorrelation and
heteroscedasticity tests are presented as follows:
i. Normality Test
The distribution of data that is considered normal is a prerequisite for the data to
be able to continue the parametric test stage, in this study the pp plot normal test
was used to see the normality of the data which can be presented as follows:
Figure 4. PP Normal Test Plot
Data Regression shows that it is around the diagonal line and follows the direction
the diagonal line, based on the test results, it can be interpreted that the data
meets the normality assumption so that it is worthy of parametric testing.
ii. Multicollinearity Test
The results of the multicollinearity test refer to the tolerance value of more than
0.1 and the VIF value of less than 10, the data is interpreted as meeting the
multicollinearity test, the test results are presented as follows:
Table 1. Tolerance and VIF test results
Tolerance
VIF
perp.as an entrepreneur
.826
1.211
perp.as a professional worker
.826
1.211
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1109 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
The test results prove that the processed data meets the required assumptions,
all independent variables have a VIF value below 10 while the tolerance value is
above 0.1 so that the data deserves to be tested parametrically.
iii. Autocorrelation Test
A good regression model avoids confounding correlations by looking at the
provisions on the Durbin-Watson (DW) value on the data being tested with a
benchmark if the DW number is between -2 to +2, it means that there is no
autocorrelation, the test results are presented as follows:
Tabel 2 Uji Durbin Watson
Mod
el
R
R Square
Adjusted R
Square
Std. Error of
the Estimate
Durbin-Watson
1
.394
a
.155
.140
6.23464
1.093
The test results show the DW value of 1.093 which is in the range of -2 to +2 with
these results it can be concluded that the data passes the autocorrelation test so
that it is feasible to carry out further tests.
iv. Heteroscedasticity Test
Whether or not the assumption of heteroscedasticity in this study uses a regression
scatterplot test which refers to the spread of points with an unclear pattern
spreading above and below the Y axis, the data passes the heteroscedasticity test.
The test results are presented as follows:
Figure 5 Scatterplot . Heteroscedasticity Test
The test data looks irregularly spread above and below the Y axis so that it is
concluded that the data meets the assumption of heteroscedasticity so that it is
feasible to do a regression test.
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1110 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
b. The Contribution of Women as Entrepreneurs and Workers to the HDI of
Women in Java
The results of the research analysis using the estimation of model parameters will
be tested partially and simultaneously to see the contribution of the independent variables
to the HDI of women in Java. This study also conducted a cross-test to see more detailed
cases with district/city level analysis tools in achieving the Women's HDI through
predictors of women's participation in professional workers and entrepreneurs. The
research data that has been processed previously has been tested for parametric
prerequisites so that it meets the classical assumption test, the test results can be
presented as follows:
Table 1. Estimated Multiple Linear Regression Model
Variable
Coefficient
Beta
t
sig
Constant
44,522
7,760
0.000
Women as entrepreneurs
0.128
0.171
1.823
0.071
Women as professional workers
0.409
0.290
3.090
0.003
R Square
F
Sig.
0.155
10.642
0.000
Source: data processed, 2021
Partially, the variable of women as entrepreneurs has a positive but not significant
impact on the HDI of women in Java, with these results it can be interpreted that the
higher the contribution of women in the field of work as entrepreneurs will increase the
HDI of women, although the contribution of women is still small in Java Island can be
seen from the percentage of HDI for women which is only 17.1 percent. Interestingly,
the findings of this study are not in line with the national research conducted by
(Abdurrahman & Tusianti, 2021) which stated that there was a positive and significant
effect of the variable of women as entrepreneurs on women's HDI. This condition shows
that the role of women in economic activities is still low, so that participation in economic
improvement has not been seen in quantity. In fact, if women take a role independently
in the field of entrepreneurship, it will certainly accelerate the increase in women's income
so that it will become a leverage in the economic dimension. This is in line with the
explanation of (Abdurrahman & Tusianti, 2021) who stated that in terms of quantity,
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1111 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
women entrepreneurs will significantly contribute to boosting purchasing power on a
macro basis in a region.
Managing an independent business for women is a challenge that is not easy, one
of which is equal access to limited business capital, both in the form of capital assistance
and access to business credit. Constraints faced include complicated administrative
requirements and the existence of collateral that is impossible for women business actors
to have, in addition to providing credit and financial assistance to women-owned
businesses, in fact, it is not gender-affirmative (Ramdlaningrum, et al., 2020). In fact, a
World Bank study states that 44 percent of women are willing to borrow to invest in
advancing the company they manage, such as buying machines, developing product and
expanding marketing compared to male business owners (40 percent) (IFC, 2016).
Various studies confirm the business management difficulties faced by SME owners
regarding financing with different levels, Informal SMEs at 19 percent, semi-formal SMEs
at 10 percent while formal SMEs at 11 percent. Another obstacle faced by SMEs regarding
competition is 66 percent, large operational/labor costs account for 37 percent (IFC,
2016). Of course, the challenges faced by women business owners will be even more
difficult when running a business in a very tight market like in Java, although the market
potential is open, the competitors who play in the same business are also quite busy. So
it is very important for women to have adequate education and knowledge before
entering the area of entrepreneurship. The contribution of women's education and
experience also has a big role in risk taking in managing women's businesses (Faridyah,
2020).
Table 2. Regional Categories by Participation of Women Entrepreneurs and
Women's HDI in 2019
as entrepreneurs
Women
Low
(<
60)
Medium
(60-
69.99)
High
(70-
79.99)
Very
high
(> 80
)
Total
Low
(<40
percent)
Count
6
8
4
0
18
% of
Total
5.0%
6.7%
3.4%
0.0%
15.1%
Medium
Count
0
36
26
7
69
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1112 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
(40 percent-
49.99
percent)
% of
Total
0.0%
30.3%
21.8%
5.9%
58.0%
High
(>50
percent)
Count
0
15
14
3
32
% of
Total
0.0%
12.6%
11.8%
2.5%
26.9%
Total
Count
6
59
44
10
119
% of
Total
5.0%
49.6%
37.0%
8.4%
100.0%
The findings of the data show that regions that have low participation of women
as entrepreneurs can in fact achieve a women's HDI in the high category (3.4 percent)
namely the Thousand Islands Regency, but the achievement of low HDI (5 percent) and
medium 6.7 percent) dominates. Meanwhile, regions with women's participation as
entrepreneurs in the high category have a better contribution to HDI achievement in the
high category as much as 11.8 percent, even very high 2.5 percent, namely Salatiga City,
Sleman and Yogyakarta City. However, regions that have a moderate level of women's
participation as entrepreneurs in fact dominate the achievement of a better HDI in all
categories of women's HDI.
Furthermore, the variable of women as professional workers has a positive and
significant impact on the HDI of women in Java, the contribution of the variable of women
as professional workers dominates the HDI of women with a large contribution of 29
percent. With these results, it can be interpreted that the higher the increase in women
entering the professional worker area will increase the HDI of women on the island of
Java. The position of women in entering the labor market is certainly different from that
of men. In order to enter the labor market, many women have to struggle through the
barricades of strict labor market prerequisites. Empirically found three explanatory factors
that influence individual decisions to enter the labor market, namely individual
characteristics (age, education, gender, marital status), household characteristics (head
of household or not) and labor market characteristics (secondary and broadcast economic
sectors, population) (Nor and Said, 2016; Anas and Damayanti, 2020).
The narrowing of the gender gap in work participation between men and women
is certainly good news, but unfortunately only happens in big cities like Jakarta. The
findings of the study by Anas and Damayanti (2020) mention that in the span of 20 years
the gender gap has narrowed in 2015 by only 29.34 percent. This means that the level
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1113 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
of discrimination in Jakarta is decreasing, but similar conditions do not occur in other
areas. So the task of local governments to encourage women's empowerment in the
economic field must be a serious concern, through various strategic programs for women,
such as skills, easy access to capital so that women have good quality and women's
independence in the economy is realized (Khairuunnisa & Supriatna, 2018).
The success of the empowerment carried out by the local government must
consider the age, education and work experience of women (Miskiyah, Ridho, Jauhari, &
Purnamasari, 2021). This condition is based on the characteristics of women, there is a
double burden to be borne. As a study states that married women are less empowered,
so when given empowerment, failure is more likely to occur (Meraj & Sadaqat, 2016).
The level of education will contribute to the decision of the owner of the company to
employ women in Indonesia, the higher the education of women, the easier it will be to
enter the tertiary employment sector compared to the primary and secondary sectors. So
this is what causes a shift in the economic structure in Indonesia due to the participation
of women workers in the tertiary sector (Wijayanto & Sari, 2019).
The government's homework in gender-based development is still large, in fact in
the range of 2010 to 2019 the HDI for women was still below the HDI for men, in 2010
the HDI for men was 70.94, increasing in 2019 to 75.96. While the HDI for women in
2010 was 63.43, there was a continuous increase but the achievement was still below
the HDI for men, in 2019 the HDI for women reached 69.18 (Kemen PPPA, 2020). The
slow increase in women's HDI is allegedly hit by structural and cultural walls, on the
structural path there is still no alignment of policy makers and implementers of gender
equality-based development programs, while on the cultural path, patriarchal culture is
deeply rooted in people's lives, so that various decisions have not properly considered
the needs of women in development participation (Kemen PPPA, 2020). Almost similar to
the description, Khairani (2017) mentions three factors that cause gender inequality to
remain lasting, namely patriarchal culture, religious teachings which are interpreted to be
highly gender-biased and the state hegemony in it is very strong. So it is true that married
women are less empowered than unmarried women (Menon & Sharma, 2020).
The backwardness of women in formal work seems to have started since the
beginning of their careers, the percentage of young women entering the formal job
market is lower than the percentage of young men, the highest percentage of young
women who work in the formal sector is achieved by the province of Bali at 44.5 percent,
on the island of Java, DKI Jakarta Province is the holder of the highest percentage of
young women entering the formal job market (Bappenas, 2019). The proportion of young
women who are still low in the formal sector is due to the low participation of young
women in the workforce, only a small proportion enter the labor market while the majority
of the rest choose to take care of the household. Sadly, the low female labor force
participation (TPAK) continues as adults, in 2019 female LFPR (51.89 percent) was far
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1114 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
behind when compared to men (83.13 percent) (Kemen PPPA, 2020). The low level of
education of women will have an impact on the positions that can be obtained in work
and the wages that women will be able to get (Castellano, Punzo, & Rocca, 2018).
However, there is still a big wall of persistence over the cultural construction that women
work in the domestic area, stereotypes, and the concept of marginalization influence work
choices that are not as free as men. Barriers to the development of women's performance
potential are very limited, only a few are able to pass so that they successfully reach the
peak of their careers but with certain consequences for making compromises in the
domestic area (Fitriyaningsih & Faizah, 2020).
Table 3. Regional Categories by Participation of Women Professional
Workers and HDI Women in 2019
Women as professional
workers
HDI
Low
(<60)
Medium
(60-69.99)
High
(70-
79.99)
Very
high
(>80)
Total
Low
(<40 percent )
Count
2
8
1
0
11
% of
Total
1.7%
6.7%
0.8%
0.0%
9.2%
Medium
(40 percent-49.99
percent)
Count
4
41
26
7
78
% of
Total
3.4%
34.5%
21.8%
5.9%
65.5%
High
(> 50 percent)
Count
0
10
17
3
30
% of
Total
0.0%
8.4%
14.3%
2.5%
25.2%
Total
Count
6
59
44
10
119
% of
Total
5.0%
49.6%
37.0%
8.4%
100.0%
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1115 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
Regions that have women's participation as professional workers in the medium
category dominate the achievement of the Women's HDI in all categories, as much as
34.5 percent are able to enter the medium category, while 21.8 percent are in the high
category, even 5.9 percent are able to achieve a very high Women's HDI. . Meanwhile,
regions that have the participation of female professional workers in the high category
are able to contribute 14.3 percent of the HDI women in the high category, as much as
8.4 percent in the medium category and only 2.5 percent in the very high category,
namely Surakarta City, Semarang City and Yogyakarta City. What is interesting is that
there is one area where the contribution of women's participation as professional workers
is in the low category but is able to achieve the HDI of women in the high category,
namely Bandung Regency.
The simultaneous contribution shows the model's ability to explain the variation of
the female HDI variable is very significant with a coefficient of determination of 15.5
percent, so it can be explained that as much as 84.5 percent of the female HDI is
influenced by variables outside the model in this study. Regions that have a high level of
gender equality correlate with the level of economic growth that can be achieved by
(Nazmi & Jamal, 2018). In addition, the existence of gender inequality is an obstacle to
the wheels of the economy, a slow-growing economy will affect income at the national
to per capita level (Karoui & Feki, 2018). Gender inequality still occurs in Indonesia due
to socio-cultural barriers, work agreements, weak regulations, and a lack of
understanding of the rights of women workers (Nuraeni & Suryono, 2021). Women who
work in public areas are generally motivated by (1) public perception of productive sector
work, (2) the motive for helping the family, (3) the process of self-actualization in the
environment, (4) the presence of prestige, a shift in the perspective of women who are
Previously it was only considered a complement but now has an equal position with the
role of men (Sabariman, 2019).
It is proper that serious attention to gender equality becomes an important
component of economic development, broad opportunities for women open up
opportunities to improve the welfare of women and their families directly (Abdullah &
Morley, 2014). The better gender-based development, the smaller the gender inequality
in a region, which will encourage high economic growth and per capita income of a region
(Sitorus, 2016); (Sari, 2021). So it is very important that the local government intervenes
through sustainable regulations, so that women workers get special rights such as
protection, wages, benefits and proper social security, as well as opportunities for self-
development through training (Aulya, 2017). This includes the rights of women workers
to naturally inherent reproduction rights, such as the right to maternity leave, maternity
leave and miscarriage (Tantimin & Sinukaban, 2021).
Women's participation in the development process is very important, participation
in various aspects shows development equality in the policy space that is equal in gender.
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1116 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
Women's participation in the economy can go through the entrepreneurial path or
become professional workers, various studies confirm that entrepreneurs have a
contribution to economic development and are the key to economic growth (Sarfaraz,
Faghih, & Majd, 2014). Women's participation in the economy is indeed closely related to
women's ease of access to education on an equal basis with men. Openness to access to
education for women is indeed something to be proud of, participation at the higher
education level is also getting higher. Young women who attended high school and
college level education increased by 2.06 points from 36.61 to 38.67 in the 20152018
period. The percentage of young women who are currently pursuing senior high school
education is also found to be higher than the percentage of young men. DI Yogyakarta
Province is the province with the highest achievement in Indonesia (61.15%) (Bappenas,
2019). Although (Arora, 2012) proves the opposite finding, that increasing access to
education and health does not affect the role of women in economic growth.
The spirit of entrepreneurship throughout the world is experiencing a gradual
increase, countries that have high entrepreneurial activity are related to the role of
entrepreneurial activities carried out by women. This awareness encourages various
countries to pay more attention to women's entrepreneurship through policies that are
friendly to women entrepreneurs (Nedelcheva, 2012). Opportunities for women
entrepreneurs to manage their own businesses are still wide open, according to (Stefan
et al., 2021) provide sustainable business development solutions for women
entrepreneurs by expanding connections, building network structures, increasing
technological capabilities to expand the market. The main key is that digital
transformation will significantly affect women's entrepreneurship.
CONCLUSION
This study has statistical evidence that simultaneously the contribution of women
as entrepreneurs and professional workers has a positive and significant impact on the
Women's Human Development Index (HDI). The greater the contribution of women as
entrepreneurs and as professional workers will increase the Women's Human
Development Index in districts/cities on the island of Java. Partially, the contribution of
women as professional workers is also positive and significant, the greater the
involvement of women in professional work will increase the achievement of the Women's
Human Development Index. However, the contribution of women as entrepreneurs has
not shown a significant contribution in forming the Women's Human Development Index
in Java.
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1117 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
REFERENCE
Abdullah, Sabah, & Morley, Bruce. (2014). Environmental taxes and economic growth:
Evidence from panel causality tests.
Energy Economics
,
42
, 2733. Elsevier.
Abdurrahman, Abdurrahman, & Tusianti, Ema. (2021). Apakah Pemberdayaan
Perempuan dalam Ekonomi dan Politik Telah Meningkatkan IPM Perempuan
Indonesia?
Jurnal Ekonomi Dan Pembangunan Indonesia
,
21
(2), 204219. Google
Scholar.
Aisyah, Fiki Dwi, & Oktavilia, Shanty. (2020). Analisis Produktivitas Tenaga Kerja Wanita
Pada Industri Rambut Palsu.
Efficient: Indonesian Journal of Development
Economics
,
3
(3), 894907. Google Scholar.
Anwas, Oos M. (2013).
Pemberdayaan masyarakat di era global
. Alfabeta. Google
Scholar.
Ardhanari, Margaretha. (2007). Analisis Personal Pumik (Perempuan Pengusaha Mikro)
Di Surabaya Dalam Upaya Pengembangan Keberhasilan Usaha Bidang Ritel Yang
Dimoderasi Faktor Kultural [Personal Analysis of Female Micro Entrepreneurs in
Surabaya in an Effort to Develop Retail Business S.
Jurnal Widya Manajemen &
Akuntansi
,
7
(2), 231243. Google Scholar.
Arora, Rashmi Umesh. (2012). Gender inequality, economic development, and
globalization: A state level analysis of India.
The Journal of Developing Areas
, 147
164. Google Scholar.
Aulya, M. K. (2017). Perlindungan Dan Hak Pekerja Perempuan Di Bidang
Ketenagakerjaan.
Jurnal Al-Maiyyah
,
10
(1), 115131. Google Scholar.
Cameron, Lisa, Suarez, Diana Contreras, & Rowell, William. (2020). Female labour force
participation in Indonesia: Why has it stalled?
Achieving Inclusive Growth in the Asia
Pacific
,
241
. Google Scholar.
Castellano, Rosalia, Punzo, Gennaro, & Rocca, Antonella. (2018). The generational
perspective of gender gap in wages and education in southern Europe.
Review of
Social Economy
,
76
(2), 227258. Taylor Francis.
Dalilah, Farahiyah. (2021). Analisis Terhadap Partisipasi Kerja Perempuan Pada Sektor
Formal di Indonesia.
Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswa FEB
,
9
(2). Google Scholar.
Faridyah, Deasy Nurmalasari. (2020). Analisis Karakteristik Dan Peran Pengusaha
Perempuan Pada Anggota Www. Umkmindonesia. Id.
Jabe (Journal of Applied
Business and Economic)
,
7
(1), 111125. Google Scholar.
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1118 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
Fitriyaningsih, Putri Dyah Ayu, & Faizah, Fita Nurotul. (2020). Relevansi Kesetaraan
Gender dan Peran Perempuan Bekerja terhadap Kesejahteraan Keluarga di Indonesia
(Perspektif Ekonomi Islam).
Jurnal Al-Maiyyah
,
13
(1). Google Scholar.
Iskandar, Yusuf, & Hamid, Abdul. (2019). Tinjauan Spasial Upah Menurut Jenis Kelamin
dan Kaitannya Dengan Indeks Kesetaraan dan Keadilan Gender di Indonesia.
Jurnal
Bisnisman: Riset Bisnis Dan Manajemen
,
1
(2), 119. Google Scholar.
Jati, Waluya. (2009). Analisis Motivasi Wirausaha Perempuan (Wirausahawati) di Kota
Malang.
Jurnal Humanity
,
4
(2). Google Scholar.
Karoui, Khayria, & Feki, Rochdi. (2018). The effect of gender inequality on economic
development: Case of African countries.
Journal of the Knowledge Economy
,
9
(1),
294300. Springer.
Khaerani, Siti Nurul. (2017). Kesetaraan dan Ketidakadilan Gender dalam Bidang Ekonomi
pada Masyarakat Tradisional Sasak di Desa Bayan Kecamatan Bayan Kabupaten
Lombok Utara.
QAWWAM
,
11
(1), 5976. Google Scholar.
Khairuunnisa, Iin, & Supriatna, Endang. (2018). Analysis of women’s economic
empowerment in Sukabumi city.
Arthatama
,
2
(1), 1525. Google Scholar.
McKinsey Global Institute. (2015).
How advancing women’s equality can add $12 trillion
to global growth
. London: McKinsey Global Institute.
McKinsey Global Institute. (2018).
The power of parity: advancing women’s equality in
asia pacific
. Brussels: McKinsey Global Institute.
Menon, Sangeetha, & Sharma, Shweta. (2020). A study on the status of women’s
empowerment in urban Bangalore, India.
Journal of International Women’s Studies
,
21
(5), 5464. Google Scholar.
Meraj, Muhammad, & Sadaqat, Mahapara. (2016). Gender equality and socio-economic
development through women’s empowerment in Pakistan.
Ritsumeikan Journal of
Asia Pacific Studies
,
34
, 124140. Google Scholar.
Miskiyah, Neneng, Ridho, Sari Lestari Z., Jauhari, Hadi, & Purnamasari, Keti. (2021).
Women Attribute and Household Level Factor on Women’s Empowerment.
Media
Ekonomi Dan Manajemen
,
36
(2), 181195. Google Scholar.
Nazmi, Lisa, & Jamal, Abd. (2018). Pengaruh Ketimpangan Gender Terhadap
Pertumbuhan Ekonomi Di Indonesia.
Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswa Ekonomi
Pembangunan
,
3
(4), 740750. Google Scholar.
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1119 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
Nedelcheva, S. (2012).
Female Entrepreneurship in Denmark. (Unpublished master’s
thesis).
Denmark: Business and Social Sciences.
Noland, Marcus, Moran, Tyler, & Kotschwar, Barbara R. (2016). Is gender diversity
profitable? Evidence from a global survey.
Peterson Institute for International
Economics Working Paper
, (163). Google Scholar.
Nuraeni, Yeni, & Suryono, Ivan Lilin. (2021). Analisis Kesetaraan Gender Dalam Bidang
Ketenagakerjaan Di Indonesia.
Nakhoda: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan
,
20
(1), 6879.
Google Scholar.
Pirmana, Viktor. (2006). Earnings differential between male-female in Indonesia:
Evidence from Sakernas data.
Departement of Economics. Bandung: Padjajaran
University
. Google Scholar.
Sabariman, Hoiril. (2019). Perempuan Pekerja (Status dan Peran Pekerja Perempuan
Penjaga Warung Makan Kurnia).
Jurnal Analisa Sosiologi
,
8
(2), 164. Google Scholar.
Safitri, Dini. (2014). Woman and Political Communication: Megawati dan Pemimpin
Simbolik.
Jurnal Komunikasi
,
9
(1), 4958. Google Scholar.
Sarfaraz, Leyla, Faghih, Nezameddin, & Majd, Armaghan Asadi. (2014). The relationship
between women entrepreneurship and gender equality.
Journal of Global
Entrepreneurship Research
,
4
(1), 111. Springer.
Sari, Cita Puspita. (2021). Gender Inequality: Dampaknya terhadap Pendapatan Per
Kapita (Studi Kasus 33 Provinsi di Indonesia 2011-2019).
Jurnal Ekonomi Dan
Statistik Indonesia
,
1
(1), 4752. Google Scholar.
Sherlywati, Sherlywati, Handayani, Rini, & Harianti, Asni. (2017). Analisis Perbandingan
Kemampuan Kewirausahaan Pengusaha Perempuan dan Laki-Laki: Studi pada UMKM
di Kota Bandung.
Jurnal Manajemen Maranatha
,
16
(2), 155166. Google Scholar.
Sitorus, Agnes Vera Yanti. (2016). Dampak ketimpangan gender terhadap pertumbuhan
ekonomi di Indonesia.
Sosio Informa: Kajian Permasalahan Sosial Dan Usaha
Kesejahteraan Sosial
,
2
(1). Google Scholar.
Stefan, Daniel, Vasile, Valentina, Oltean, Anca, Comes, Calin Adrian, Stefan, Anamari
Beatrice, Ciucan-Rusu, Liviu, Bunduchi, Elena, Popa, Maria Alexandra, & Timus,
Mihai. (2021). Women entrepreneurship and sustainable business development: Key
findings from a SWOTAHP analysis.
Sustainability
,
13
(9), 5298. Google Scholar.
Tantimin, Tantimin, & Sinukaban, Elizabeth. (2021). Perlindungan Hukum Terhadap Hak
Tenaga Kerja Perempuan Terkait Ketidaksetaraan Gender Di Indonesia.
Nusantara:
Women's Contribution as Professionals and Women as Entrepreneurs To The Women's Human
Development Index (IPM) In Java Island
1120 Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, Vol 1 (9), Juni 2022
Jurnal Ilmu Pengetahuan Sosial
,
8
(3), 395406. Google Scholar.
Wijayanto, Andi Yhudo, & Sari, Dyah Wulan. (2019). Analysis of decision to work of
female workers in Indonesia.
Economics Development Analysis Journal
,
8
(3), 290
300. Google Scholar.
Yaish, Meir, & Kraus, Vered. (2003). The consequences of economic restructuring for the
gender earnings gap in Israel, 1972-1995.
Work, Employment and Society
,
17
(1), 5
28. Google Scholar.
Yuliati, Uci. (2019). Analisis Peran Ganda Wanita sebagai Pekerja Paruh Waktu pada
Masyarakat Pedesaan di Kecamatan Junrejo Kota Batu.
Jurnal Perempuan Dan Anak
,
2
(2), 2334. Google Scholar.
Copyright holder :
Qurrota Ayun¹, Imam Mukhlis
2
(2022)
First publication right :
Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science
This article is licensed under: